What crosses her face isn't exactly surprise or even shock. It snaps past that into outrage, that he could do something so horrible (because she knows instantly what he did, before she even asked), that he had the gall to pose as her boyfriend, that she ever trusted her heart to this bastard.
"You murdered him." It's a heated, furious, but dead-certain statement of fact. Accusations imply some degree of uncertainty, and Prue is too furious for that. Of course she is, after weeks of turning her life upside-down to help their family, torturing herself about her role in not saving him, about leaving Dean in that prison to die. After weeks of him soothing her and listening to her guilt, and-
Another realization follows. That day when she told him (again) how sorry she was, when he latched into her like that and wouldn't let go and for the first time refused to let her retreat from him. When he didn't let her back away, and asked her why, and asked her (again) about that incident on the baseball field and asked her why she was hiding, and finally convinced her to trust him enough to make a final step she had to be sweet-talked into.
no subject
"You murdered him." It's a heated, furious, but dead-certain statement of fact. Accusations imply some degree of uncertainty, and Prue is too furious for that. Of course she is, after weeks of turning her life upside-down to help their family, torturing herself about her role in not saving him, about leaving Dean in that prison to die. After weeks of him soothing her and listening to her guilt, and-
Another realization follows. That day when she told him (again) how sorry she was, when he latched into her like that and wouldn't let go and for the first time refused to let her retreat from him. When he didn't let her back away, and asked her why, and asked her (again) about that incident on the baseball field and asked her why she was hiding, and finally convinced her to trust him enough to make a final step she had to be sweet-talked into.
That bastard. "You used me. Didn't you?"
That fucking bastard.